On Motion to Recommit with Instructions

Failed
Ask AI

Sponsor: Rep. Gosar, Paul A. [R-AZ-4] · AZ

Summary

(This measure has not been amended since it was reported to the House on March 15, 2017. The summary of that version is repeated here.)

Competitive Health Insurance Reform Act of 2017

(Sec. 2) This bill amends the McCarran-Ferguson Act to declare that nothing in that Act modifies, impairs, or supersedes the operation of antitrust laws with respect to the business of health insurance, including the business of dental insurance. This declaration does not apply to a contract, combination, or conspiracy to: (1) collect, compile, or disseminate historical loss data; (2) determine a loss development factor for historical loss data; (3) perform actuarial services if the collaboration does not involve a restraint of trade; or (4) develop or disseminate a standard insurance policy form if adherence to the form is not required.

Prohibitions against unfair methods of competition apply to the business of health insurance without regard to whether the business is for profit.

Yea 189 (44%)(54%) 233 Nay

7 present / not voting

Party Split

Democrat
187 Yea0 Nay6 Other
Republican
2 Yea233 Nay1 Other
Member Votes429

Yes (189)

AdamsD-NC
AguilarD-CA
Bishop (GA)D-GA
BlumenauerD-OR
Brady (PA)D-PA
ButterfieldD-NC
BassD-CA
BonamiciD-OR
BeattyD-OH
Brownley (CA)D-CA
BustosD-IL
BeraD-CA
BeyerD-VA
BlumR-IA
Boyle, Brendan F.D-PA
BarraganD-CA
Blunt RochesterD-DE
Brown (MD)D-MD
ClyburnD-SC
ConyersD-MI
CooperD-TN
CummingsD-MD
CapuanoD-MA
CrowleyD-NY
ClayD-MO
CostaD-CA
CleaverD-MO
CuellarD-TX
Castor (FL)D-FL
Clarke (NY)D-NY
CohenD-TN
CourtneyD-CT
Carson (IN)D-IN
ConnollyD-VA
Chu, JudyD-CA
CicillineD-RI
CartwrightD-PA
Castro (TX)D-TX
CardenasD-CA
Clark (MA)D-MA
CorreaD-CA
CristD-FL
CarbajalD-CA
Davis, DannyD-IL
DeFazioD-OR
DeGetteD-CO
DeLauroD-CT
DoggettD-TX
Doyle, Michael F.D-PA
Davis (CA)D-CA
DeutchD-FL
DelBeneD-WA
DelaneyD-MD
DeSaulnierD-CA
DingellD-MI
DemingsD-FL
EngelD-NY
EshooD-CA
EllisonD-MN
EstyD-CT
EvansD-PA
EspaillatD-NY
FosterD-IL
FudgeD-OH
Frankel (FL)D-FL
Green, GeneD-TX
GutierrezD-IL
GrijalvaD-AZ
Green, AlD-TX
GaramendiD-CA
GabbardD-HI
GallegoD-AZ
Gonzalez (TX)D-TX
GottheimerD-NJ
HastingsD-FL
HoyerD-MD
Higgins (NY)D-NY
HimesD-CT
HanabusaD-HI
HeckD-WA
HuffmanD-CA
Jackson LeeD-TX
Johnson, E. B.D-TX
JonesR-NC
Johnson (GA)D-GA
JeffriesD-NY
JayapalD-WA
KapturD-OH
KindD-WI
KeatingD-MA
KennedyD-MA
KildeeD-MI
KilmerD-WA
Kuster (NH)D-NH
Kelly (IL)D-IL
KhannaD-CA
KihuenD-NV
KrishnamoorthiD-IL
LevinD-MI
Lewis (GA)D-GA
LofgrenD-CA
LoweyD-NY
LeeD-CA
Larson (CT)D-CT
LangevinD-RI
Larsen (WA)D-WA
LynchD-MA
LipinskiD-IL
LoebsackD-IA
Lujan, Ben RayD-NM
LowenthalD-CA
Lujan Grisham, M.D-NM
LawrenceD-MI
Lieu, TedD-CA
Lawson (FL)D-FL
McGovernD-MA
MeeksD-NY
McCollumD-MN
MooreD-WI
MatsuiD-CA
McNerneyD-CA
Maloney, SeanD-NY
MengD-NY
MoultonD-MA
McEachinD-VA
Murphy (FL)D-FL
NadlerD-NY
NealD-MA
NolanD-MN
NapolitanoD-CA
NorcrossD-NJ
O'RourkeD-TX
O'HalleranD-AZ
PalloneD-NJ
PascrellD-NJ
PelosiD-CA
PetersonD-MN
Price (NC)D-NC
PerlmutterD-CO
PingreeD-ME
PolisD-CO
PocanD-WI
PetersD-CA
PanettaD-CA
QuigleyD-IL
Roybal-AllardD-CA
RuppersbergerD-MD
Ryan (OH)D-OH
RichmondD-LA
RuizD-CA
Rice (NY)D-NY
RaskinD-MD
RosenD-NV
Scott (VA)D-VA
SerranoD-NY
ShermanD-CA
Smith (WA)D-WA
SchakowskyD-IL
SchiffD-CA
SanchezD-CA
Scott, DavidD-GA
SiresD-NJ
SarbanesD-MD
Shea-PorterD-NH
SpeierD-CA
SchraderD-OR
Sewell (AL)D-AL
SchneiderD-IL
Swalwell (CA)D-CA
SotoD-FL
SuozziD-NY
Thompson (MS)D-MS
Thompson (CA)D-CA
TitusD-NV
TonkoD-NY
TakanoD-CA
TorresD-CA
VelazquezD-NY
ViscloskyD-IN
VargasD-CA
VeaseyD-TX
VelaD-TX
Waters, MaxineD-CA
Wasserman SchultzD-FL
WalzD-MN
WelchD-VT
Wilson (FL)D-FL
Watson ColemanD-NJ
YarmuthD-KY

Abstained (0)

None

No (233)

AderholtR-AL
AmashR-MI
AmodeiR-NV
AllenR-GA
AbrahamR-LA
ArringtonR-TX
BartonR-TX
Brady (TX)R-TX
BlackburnR-TN
BurgessR-TX
Bishop (UT)R-UT
BilirakisR-FL
BuchananR-FL
BarlettaR-PA
BlackR-TN
Brooks (AL)R-AL
BucshonR-IN
BarrR-KY
BridenstineR-OK
Brooks (IN)R-IN
ByrneR-AL
BratR-VA
BabinR-TX
Bishop (MI)R-MI
BostR-IL
BuckR-CO
BaconR-NE
Banks (IN)R-IN
BergmanR-MI
BiggsR-AZ
BuddR-NC
CalvertR-CA
ChabotR-OH
CulbersonR-TX
Carter (TX)R-TX
ColeR-OK
ConawayR-TX
ChaffetzR-UT
CoffmanR-CO
CrawfordR-AR
Collins (NY)R-NY
Collins (GA)R-GA
CookR-CA
CramerR-ND
Carter (GA)R-GA
ComstockR-VA
Costello (PA)R-PA
Curbelo (FL)R-FL
ComerR-KY
CheneyR-WY
Duncan (TN)R-TN
Diaz-BalartR-FL
DentR-PA
DenhamR-CA
DuffyR-WI
Duncan (SC)R-SC
DesJarlaisR-TN
Davis, RodneyR-IL
DeSantisR-FL
DonovanR-NY
DavidsonR-OH
DunnR-FL
EmmerR-MN
FrelinghuysenR-NJ
Franks (AZ)R-AZ
FortenberryR-NE
FoxxR-NC
FleischmannR-TN
FarentholdR-TX
FloresR-TX
FasoR-NY
FergusonR-GA
FitzpatrickR-PA
GoodlatteR-VA
GrangerR-TX
Graves (MO)R-MO
GohmertR-TX
GuthrieR-KY
Graves (GA)R-GA
GibbsR-OH
GosarR-AZ
GowdyR-SC
GriffithR-VA
GrothmanR-WI
Graves (LA)R-LA
GaetzR-FL
GallagherR-WI
GarrettR-VA
HensarlingR-TX
HarperR-MS
HunterR-CA
HarrisR-MD
HartzlerR-MO
Herrera BeutlerR-WA
HuizengaR-MI
HultgrenR-IL
HoldingR-NC
HudsonR-NC
Hice, Jody B.R-GA
HillR-AR
HurdR-TX
HollingsworthR-IN
Higgins (LA)R-LA
IssaR-CA
Johnson, SamR-TX
JordanR-OH
Jenkins (KS)R-KS
Johnson (OH)R-OH
Joyce (OH)R-OH
Jenkins (WV)R-WV
Johnson (LA)R-LA
King (NY)R-NY
Kelly (PA)R-PA
KinzingerR-IL
KatkoR-NY
KnightR-CA
Kelly (MS)R-MS
Kustoff (TN)R-TN
LucasR-OK
LoBiondoR-NJ
LambornR-CO
LattaR-OH
LanceR-NJ
LuetkemeyerR-MO
LabradorR-ID
LongR-MO
LaMalfaR-CA
LoudermilkR-GA
LoveR-UT
LaHoodR-IL
Lewis (MN)R-MN
Murphy (PA)R-PA
McHenryR-NC
McCaulR-TX
MarchantR-TX
McMorris RodgersR-WA
McCarthyR-CA
McClintockR-CA
MarinoR-PA
McKinleyR-WV
MeehanR-PA
MassieR-KY
MeadowsR-NC
MesserR-IN
MullinR-OK
MacArthurR-NJ
MoolenaarR-MI
Mooney (WV)R-WV
McSallyR-AZ
MarshallR-KS
MastR-FL
MitchellR-MI
NunesR-CA
NoemR-SD
NewhouseR-WA
OlsonR-TX
PearceR-NM
Poe (TX)R-TX
PaulsenR-MN
PoseyR-FL
PalazzoR-MS
PerryR-PA
PittengerR-NC
PalmerR-AL
PoliquinR-ME
Rogers (KY)R-KY
RohrabacherR-CA
Ros-LehtinenR-FL
Royce (CA)R-CA
Rogers (AL)R-AL
ReichertR-WA
RoskamR-IL
Roe (TN)R-TN
Rooney, Thomas J.R-FL
ReedR-NY
RenacciR-OH
RobyR-AL
RokitaR-IN
RossR-FL
Rice (SC)R-SC
RothfusR-PA
RatcliffeR-TX
RouzerR-NC
RussellR-OK
Rooney, FrancisR-FL
RutherfordR-FL
SanfordR-SC
SensenbrennerR-WI
SessionsR-TX
ShimkusR-IL
Smith (NJ)R-NJ
Smith (TX)R-TX
SimpsonR-ID
ShusterR-PA
Smith (NE)R-NE
ScaliseR-LA
SchweikertR-AZ
StiversR-OH
Scott, AustinR-GA
StewartR-UT
Smith (MO)R-MO
StefanikR-NY
SmuckerR-PA
ThornberryR-TX
TiberiR-OH
TurnerR-OH
Thompson (PA)R-PA
TiptonR-CO
TrottR-MI
TaylorR-VA
TenneyR-NY
UptonR-MI
ValadaoR-CA
WaldenR-OR
Wilson (SC)R-SC
WalbergR-MI
WittmanR-VA
Webster (FL)R-FL
WomackR-AR
WoodallR-GA
WagnerR-MO
WalorskiR-IN
Weber (TX)R-TX
WenstrupR-OH
WilliamsR-TX
WalkerR-NC
Walters, MimiR-CA
WestermanR-AR
Young (AK)R-AK
YoderR-KS
YohoR-FL
Young (IA)R-IA
ZeldinR-NY

Absent (7)

King (IA)R-IA
Maloney, Carolyn B.D-NY
PayneD-NJ
RushD-IL
SlaughterD-NY
SinemaD-AZ
TsongasD-MA
House Vote 4042 — Informed